Do you want the best rental car deal?

There are so many options when it comes to booking the best rental car deal these days. But how do you actually know who’s got the better deal?  Due to this, we’ve compared two of the most popular choices for car rental in the U.S to see who is better value for money. Therefore, see below to discover our comparison between these two rental car companies.

It’s Hertz vs. Avis in the rental car face-off!


Hertz Vs Avis Best Rental Car Deal Article Hertz Logo

✔ Best price guarantee – will refund the difference in the event that you find a cheaper price.

✔ No cancellation or amendment fees – If you change your mind, you’ve got a 7 day cooling off period.

✔ Express return even after hours –  fill out the express return slip, drop the keys in the box and go!

✔ Theft and damage included – no hidden extras to pay.

✔ Multiple refuel options – prepaid option available.

✔ Courtesy shuttle bus at participating airports.

✔ No credit card fees.

Payment methods with Hertz – Can you use debit cards?

Yes, even for I.D! There are a few exceptions though, but Hertz is a lot more accommodating than Avis. You will need to provide two other valid forms of identification, but they’ll still let you book and pay with a debit card. For more information on this click on the link below and enter your location for the most up to date information.

Hertz Qualifications & Requirements (Information correct as of 5/2/2018)


Hertz Vs Avis Best Rental Car Deal Article Avis Logo

✔ Price match with a few catches – rental must be prepaid, comparison base rate must be found within 24 hours of booking.

✔ Save around $50 or more when you prepay your rental (depending on vehicle type).

✔ Veteran and Military Family Benefits can receive discounts from top brands, and up to 25% off from Avis.

✔ Long term rentals available with no minimum day requirement.

✔ Multiple refuel options – prepaid option available.

Avis’ Price Match – The Catch

To get your price match, plus 10% off your rental, there are a few stipulations and exceptions. Here is the gist of it:

✔ You must book your prepaid rental at least 72 hours in advance of pick up.

✔ The submitted comparison base rate must be found within 24 hours of booking your Avis rental.

✔ The comparison base rate must have the same reservation dates and times, pick-up and drop-off locations, and rental car type as your prepaid Avis rental.

✔ You have to submit a form online and it needs to be approved which takes up to 10 days from the date of submission.

More Exceptions:

Hertz Vs Avis Best Rental Car Deal Article Keys Purse

You won’t qualify for the ‘Best Price Guarantee’ if you:

1. Find a better rate from other car rental companies (including but not limited to Budget, National, Enterprise, Alamo, Sixt, Dollar, Payless, etc. you don’t qualify for the price match guarantee.

2.  If you’ve used a discount code, coupon or another offer.

3. Rent a car as part of a package rate (e.g. airfare + hotel + car rental, hotel + car rental, airfare + car rental).

And the list goes on. Too many catches for a measly extra 10%? This is further compromised by the fact that you’ll also incur a $50 processing fee if you choose to cancel your reservation before the rental.  So what’s the point?

To see the full list of stipulations, check out the link below.

Avis Best Rate Guarantee (Information correct at 5/3/2018).

Avis Cancellation Policy (Information correct at 5/3/2018).

The Avis Payment Options

Ok, so you can pay with a debit card, but only at participating locations, which you’ll have to inquire about by giving them a call. The catch is, they will request an authorization hold against your account for the estimated charges of the rental, plus any extras that they deem appropriate.

Can I use my debit card as I.D?

Yes, you can, with the following conditions.

The long and short of it with Avis is that you will need a credit card or at least a debit card that bears the Visa or MasterCard logo. You will need to be at least 25 years old to use a debit card as identification too. More details are available in the ‘forms of payment’ section via the link below.

Avis Debit Card Policies

So who is cheaper?

Hertz Vs Avis Best Rental Car Deal Article Car Walk

In conclusion, we’ve looked at two similar economy car rental options for the same dates and locations pick-up/drop-off points.  As a result of this search, it seemed Hertz definitely came out on top with the better price and better deal!

Check out the price difference! Hertz even includes their LDW (Loss, Damage Waiver), and still comes out on top. Both options had unlimited mileage.

Start Booking Your Rental Cars

Was this helpful?